Sharvada Sharma's suspension, suspension without pay and termination were unconstitutional - High Court
Court orders Sharma to be paid about $3.1m

Sharvada Sharma's suspension, suspension without pay and termination were unconstitutional - High Court

Court orders Sharma to be paid about $3.1m

By Vijay Narayan , Rashika Kumar
Wednesday 24/01/2024
Former Solicitor General, Sharvada Sharma

High Court Judge, Justice Deepthi Amaratunga has ruled that the termination, suspension, suspension without salary decision was unlawful and taken without proper procedure and has declared all decision null and void.

He has ruled the advice given to President Jioji Konrote to suspend the Solicitor General, Sharvada Sharma in 2021 was against the Constitution and Sharma’s termination was illegal.

This is because a tribunal was not appointed to look into the allegations made against Sharma by former Supervisor of Elections, Mohammed Saneem.

The Judge has ordered that Sharma will not be reinstated but be compensated about $3.1 million as loss of income and damages.

He says considering all the circumstances, in his mind Sharma’s remedies should be confined to damages and they are assessed as his lost income for the 51 day period of his suspension amounting to $27,913.49 gross plus 8 percent Fiji National Provident Fund of $2,233.08; special damages for his lost income from 10th November 2021 to the date of the hearing which is 581 days at the rate of $199,773 per annum amounting to $317,994.83, from which credit must be given for the $130,373.84 he will have earned from USP that is net $187,620.99 per annum plus 8 percent FNPF contribution of $15,009.68; loss to future earnings where a multiplier of 10 is used considering the circumstances that Sharma has good prospects of employability considering his experience and qualificaitons and other uncertainties in 22 year time until his retirement at the age of 70.

For multiplier, his annual salary at the time of termination $221,971 per annum so future loss multiplied by 10 is $2,219,710 and 8 percent FNPF of $177,576.80.

Sharma had applied for a judicial review against his termination.

The ruling was deferred 9 times since last year.

Sharma had taken legal action against the President of Fiji, the Judicial Services Commission and the Attorney General of Fiji in relation to the termination of his employment on 10th of November, 2021 by former President Jioji Konrote.

Under sections 112 and 116 of the Constitution, the Solicitor General can only be removed from office after a proper inquiry by an independent tribunal.

In Sharma’s case, no tribunal inquiry was held.

During the case, Sharvada Sharma’s lawyer, Jon Apted had argued that Sharma’s dismissal was in breach of the relevant provisions of the constitution governing process.

He had said that Sharma was not accorded common law rights to natural justice.

R Patel Lawyers partner Devanesh Sharma who was representing the Attorney General, President of Fiji and the Judicial Services Commission had revealed details in court about the complaint to the Judicial Services Commission by the then Supervisor of Elections, Mohammed Saneem against the then Solicitor General, Sharvada Sharma.

The complaint was made after Sharma who represented the Supervisor of Elections, lost the Niko Nawaikula case.

Devanesh Sharma said Saneem had said that he was not consulted prior to submissions being filed by Sharvada Sharma.

FEATURE NEWS
2 out 3 of women in every church in Fiji experience domestic violence – Rev. Bhagwan
2 out of 3 women in every church in Fiji experience physical or sexual violence in their lifetime, and there are uncomfortable truths that need to be ...
4 hours ago
LATEST NEWS
Prof. Biman Prasad to appear on fijivillage Straight Talk With Vijay Narayan at 7pm Wednesday
Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Finance, Professor Biman Prasad will appear on fijivillage Straight With Vijay Narayan at 7pm ...
3 hours ago

Students disappointed as MGM High School cancels Year 13 graduation over unpaid walk-a-thon pledges
MGM High School students are raising concerns as the school will not be holding a graduation ceremony for Year 13 students this year, as some ...
4 hours ago

COP29: Charan Jeath Singh tells Ketan Lal to refund money spent on him while Lal says Singh added little value at meetings
Minister for Sugar Industry, Charan Jeath Singh has told Opposition bloc of 16 member Ketan Lal to refund his air ticket and per diem claims to the ...
4 hours ago

Bail extended for $296,000 LTA scam duo
The Lautoka Magistrates Court has extended the bail for the couple who were allegedly involved in a $296,000 taxi permit scam. Land Transport ...
5 hours ago

Kiran defends Fiji delegation’s efforts at COP29 amid criticism from Charan Jeath Singh
Assistant Minister for Women Sashi Kiran has highlighted the commitment and tenacity of the Fijian delegation and has paid tribute to those who have ...
5 hours ago



fijivillage Straight Talk with Vijay Narayan
Latest Videos

Stay tuned for the latest news on our radio stations

CFL radio frequencies
yb
IN DEPTH
Doctor Alipate Vakamocea on fijivillage Straight Talk with Vijay Narayan
Fiji Medical Association President, Doctor Alipate Vakamocea will appear on fijivillage Straight Talk with Vijay Narayan The show will focus on ...
9 days ago

Mangal and Akauola on fijivillage Straight Talk With Vijay Narayan
Adult Teen Challenge Fiji Executive Director, Hemraj Mangal and Director, Matai Akauola appear on fijivillage Straight Talk With Vijay Narayan The ...
9 days ago

Sporting federations demand answers from FASANOC
National sporting federations who are part of Fiji Association of Sport and National Olympic Committee or FASANOC, are still calling for answers and ...
16 days ago

TOP