Justice Goundar to deliver ruling next month on whether case against Richard Naidu will continue or there will be fresh proceedings

Justice Goundar to deliver ruling next month on whether case against Richard Naidu will continue or there will be fresh proceedings

By Rashika Kumar
13/06/2023
Suva lawyer Richard Naidu leaving court.

Suva High Court Judge Justice Daniel Goundar will deliver his ruling on the 14th of July on whether the contempt of court case against Suva lawyer Richard Naidu will continue or fresh proceedings will begin.

Naidu was found guilty in November last year by High Court Judge Justice Jude Nanayakkara for contempt scandalising the court.

Naidu posted on his Facebook page a picture of a judgement in a case represented by his associate that had the word 'injunction' misspelt, and then made some comments that he was pretty sure the applicant wanted an injunction.

The committal proceeding was brought against Naidu by the then Attorney General, Aiyaz Sayed-Khaiyum.

Naidu is represented by Jon Apted while Feizal Haniff is now representing the Attorney General.

The matter is before Justice Gounder as Justice Nanayakkara tendered in his resignation earlier this year.

Justice Gounder says he is seeking clarification if he still has jurisdiction to proceed with the substantive matter.

Apted says the issue is that the civil matter is partially heard and under normal civil procedure rules, when a new judge takes over a partly heard substantive matter, the judge only continues with the consent of the parties.

He says they are not objecting to any judge taking over the substantive matter. Apted says if the judge hears the application from the beginning, that would have the similar effect to set aside the ruling.

The lawyer says at that point, it is up to the Office of the Attorney General to discontinue the proceeding before the proceeding begins again.

Apted has clarified it is not an objection to Justice Gounder but it is about what procedure applies on the substantive application for committal.

He says the application to set aside the ruling is not an initiation of fresh proceedings but an interlocutory application within the existing one.

Apted further says if the judge rehears, it would be open at that stage to the applicant to discontinue and rehearing in fact would mean the ruling that found Naidu guilty is somehow gone as well.

Apted adds in criminal proceedings, Justice Gounder would have proceeded to sentencing but this is a civil matter and they are submitting that the normal civil procedure would apply.

FEATURE NEWS
Ratu Tevita Mara to be installed as Tui Nayau today on Nayau Island
Ratu Tevita Uluilakeba Mara will be installed as Tui Nayau today on Nayau Island. The title has been left vacant for more than 20 years following t...
1 hour ago
LATEST NEWS
King Tupou VI and Queen Nanasipau’u of Tonga to begin historic State visit to Fiji today
In a landmark diplomatic engagement for the Pacific region, Fiji will welcome King Tupou VI and Queen Nanasipau’u, of the Kingdom of Tonga for a ...
1 hour ago

Team Fiji: Young, Miller, Karan and Qaqa win gold at the Pacific Mini Games in Palau
Heleina Young, Frederico Miller, Yeshnil Karan and Errol Qaqa all secured gold medals for Fiji at the Pacific Mini Games in Palau. Young says she ...
1 hour ago

Lineage of Ratu Tevita Uluilakeba Mara traced back to Ratu Seru Cakobau - Ratu Kalivati
The Vanua of Bau recognises the installation of the Tui Nayau and the Sau ni Vanua o Lau, Ratu Tevita Uluilakeba Mara, as a sign of respect and ...
15 hours ago

Danger zone : Pac Harbour Fire Station closes this Friday due to NFA relocation issues
Pacific Harbour Fire Station is closing down as the plot is owned by Damodar Yatu Lau Pte Limited which has taken it back for development and the ...
15 hours ago

Chaudhry asks whether PM is related to Acting FICAC Commissioner and raises issue that PM cannot recommend who should be head of FICAC
Serious concerns are now being raised by Fiji Labour Party Leader, Mahendra Chaudhry on whether Acting FICAC Commissioner, Lavi Rokoika is related to ...
15 hours ago



fijivillage Straight Talk with Vijay Narayan
Latest Videos

Stay tuned for the latest news on our radio stations

CFL radio frequencies
IN DEPTH
Tui Nayau and Tui Lau Installation
The ceremony for the installation of the Tui Nayau Sau ni Vanua o Lau will be held tomorrow, while the installation ceremony of the Tui Lau will be held in Tubou on Thursday.
20 hours ago

CFL 40th Birthday
CFL’s 40th Anniversary celebrations to culminate with free concert at Albert Park on ...
4 days ago

Pacific Mini Games in Palau, 2025
Full coverage of Team Fiji's journey through the 2025 Palau Games.
5 days ago

TOP