If the Electoral Bill is passed tomorrow, the powers to be given to the Supervisor are really concerning – Law Society
Fines or prison terms or both can apply if a ‘person’ fails to comply

If the Electoral Bill is passed tomorrow, the powers to be given to the Supervisor are really concerning – Law Society

Fines or prison terms or both can apply if a ‘person’ fails to comply

By Vijay Narayan
31/08/2022
Fiji Law Society President Wylie Clarke

The Electoral Amendment Bill that will be debated and voted on in Parliament tomorrow states that if the Supervisor of Elections has reason to believe that a person has information or documents relevant to or required by the Supervisor for the performance of his or her functions under the Electoral Act, the Supervisor must, by notice in writing, direct the person to furnish such information or documents to the Supervisor.

The Fiji Law Society says if the Bill is passed tomorrow, these powers to be given to the Supervisor are really concerning.

Any person who, having been lawfully required under the section of the Act to disclose any information or document to the Supervisor must, notwithstanding the provisions of any other written law on confidentiality, privilege or secrecy, comply with such direction.

Any person who fails to comply with the directions of the Supervisor or provides information that is false, commits an offence and is liable on conviction, in the case of a natural person, to a fine not exceeding $50,000 or a term of imprisonment not exceeding 5 years or both; and in the case of a company, association or body of persons, whether corporate or unincorporated, government department, nongovernmental organisation, statutory authority or any other entity, to a fine not exceeding $500,000 and for the director, chief executive officer, minister, manager or officer in charge for the time being, to a fine not exceeding $50,000 or a term of imprisonment not exceeding 5 years or both. While moving the motion for the Bill to be debated and voted on without delay, Attorney General, Aiyaz Sayed-Khaiyum said that Clause 2 of the Bill amends the Electoral Act by redefining the term “person” to mean a natural or legal person and includes a company, association or body of person, whether corporate or unincorporated, government department, nongovernmental organisation, statutory authority or any other entity.

He says the proposed amendments provide for the powers of the Supervisor of Elections necessary to carry out his or her functions under the Act, including the power to direct a person, by notice in writing, to furnish any relevant information or document.

Sayed-Khaiyum says without this specific power, the Supervisor is unable to make enquiries to obtain information necessary for the Supervisor to arrive at decisions as required by the Act.

He says such powers are also extremely important to allow the Supervisor to conduct enquiries into allegations of breaches of campaign provisions.

The Fiji Law Society is calling upon the Government to withdraw Bill No.49 from Parliament so that adequate time can be given to consider all of its legal and civil rights ramifications.

Society President, Wylie Clarke says the amendment would give to the Supervisor of Elections power to compel any person to provide to him all or any information or documents on virtually any pretext.

Clarke says the proposed changes are inconsistent with the international core values and principles to which Fiji has committed itself, including long established legal principles on legal professional privilege.

Clarke says they erode civil rights protections long protected by the law.

The Fiji Law Society President says the proposed electoral amendments unnecessarily extend the powers of the Supervisor beyond those necessary to fulfil his duties and powers under the Electoral Act.

He says they encroach on and duplicate powers of investigation that are already vested in the FICAC.

Clarke says if the Supervisor reasonably suspects that an offence has been committed under the Electoral Act, he can - as he has done many times already - report the matter to FICAC which will then exercise its powers of investigation.

The Law Society President says the attack on legal professional privilege is particularly serious.

He says the reason the privilege exists is to enable people to take legal advice on any action they wish to take (or not to take) in the knowledge that in doing so they have protection.

The privilege means that no one in authority can use their questions, or the advice they receive, as evidence against them of some improper or unlawful intent. Clarke says if this privilege is taken away, people cannot take advice on their legal rights and cannot exercise them to the fullest extent and may end up breaching laws.

He says encouraging compliance with the law is the practice of democratic countries which support the rule of law.

Clarke says this Bill appears likely to be passed into law under urgency.

The Society is also very concerned that the Bill also provides no protections or safeguards for the information the Supervisor obtains in terms of how it will be used or kept.

Clarke says the Supervisor is not required to maintain confidentiality or secrecy in relation to the information and it appears such information can be used for any purpose the Supervisor chooses.

He also says there is no right of appeal against a decision of the Supervisor other than to the Fijian Electoral Commission which is final and cannot be further appealed to or reviewed by any court.

2022-2023 Budget Coverage



-->
FEATURE NEWS
Pacific Mini Games: Heleina Young and Naibili Vatunisolo secure golds for Team Fiji
Sprint sensation Heleina Young has secured another gold for Team Fiji after clocking 24.01 seconds in the Women’s 200 metres final at the Pacific Mi...
1 hour ago
LATEST NEWS
FICAC addresses oversight in Sayed-Khaiyum case
FICAC has acknowledged the public and media attention surrounding the arrest and charge of former Chief Executive Officer of the Fijian Broadcasting ...
1 hour ago

Flying Fijians focus on refining skills ahead of Scotland clash
The Fiji Water Flying Fijians are sharpening their focus ahead of their upcoming test match against Scotland this Saturday. Head Coach Mick Byrne ...
1 hour ago

Damodar offers NFA extension to remain at Arts Village site until July 2026
Damodar Group CEO Div Damodar confirms that the National Fire Authority has been offered by Damodar Yatulau Pte Limited to remain on their property ...
15 hours ago

Increased police funding to target crime in red zone areas – Prof. Prasad
The increased funding for the Fiji Police Force will allow officers to target crime in red zone areas such as Suva, Nadi and Lautoka, especially ...
15 hours ago

FICAC says no comments on Chaudhry statement nor on any queries by MPs or wanna-be MPs
FICAC has today said that it will not be providing any comments on the statement issued by the Leader of the Fiji Labour Party, Mahendra Chaudhry, ...
15 hours ago



fijivillage Straight Talk with Vijay Narayan
Latest Videos

Stay tuned for the latest news on our radio stations

CFL radio frequencies
IN DEPTH
Tui Nayau and Tui Lau Installation
The ceremony for the installation of the Tui Nayau Sau ni Vanua o Lau will be held tomorrow, while the installation ceremony of the Tui Lau will be held in Tubou on Thursday.
2 days ago

CFL 40th Birthday
CFL’s 40th Anniversary celebrations to culminate with free concert at Albert Park on ...
5 days ago

Pacific Mini Games in Palau, 2025
Full coverage of Team Fiji's journey through the 2025 Palau Games.
6 days ago

TOP