Court to rule in April on constitutionality of electoral law amendment challenged by 7 women

Court to rule in April on constitutionality of electoral law amendment challenged by 7 women

By Rashika Kumar
11/12/2024

The High Court will rule whether the amendments in the Electoral Registration of Voters Amendment Act and the Interpretation Act in 2021 that required women to change their name on the birth certificate to their married name was constitutional or not on the 14th of April next year.

The matter was heard before High Court Judge, Justice Dane Tuiqereqere where 7 women had challenged the amendments and had filed the matter against the Attorney General, the Supervisor of Elections and the State.

The lawyer of the 7 women, Jon Apted says they seek the declaration that the amendment from when it was passed to when it was repealed had breached their Bill of Rights under the Constitution.

He says although the amendments have been repealed, the challenge before the court is not moot.

He says the Attorney General, the State and the Supervisor of Elections do not concede that it was not constitutional and therefore it is a possibility that they may reintroduce it.

The lawyer says the fact that it has been repealed does not prevent the court from declaring that it was inconsistent with the Constitution.

He also says that the birth certificate does not prove eligibility to vote as it shows that a person was born on a particular date in Fiji and it also does not show citizenship.

Apted further says there is a public need to define and remind the legislature about the Bill of Rights.

He says the defendants do not acknowledge any form of accountability so the court needs to make a declaration that the legislature is subject to the court.

The lawyer also says that no evidence was provided that there was a problem with the previous law and that anyone was registered multiple times in the voter list.

Lawyer for the State and the Attorney General, Cynthia Mangru is calling for the dismissal of the claim as moot as provisions have been repealed.

She says since it is repealed, it is no longer a live controversy.

Mangru says that without Parliament as a party to these proceedings, the declaration sought lacks a proper nexus to the body that is constitutionally responsible for the amendment.

She says it is not a role the court to pass a judgment on a law the Parliament, as appropriate authority, has already recognized as requiring the amended and to do so, approaches upon the legislative domain.

The lawyer further says the law did not breach the rights of the women as they had a choice, ample time was given and there is no evidence that they were restrained from voting.

She adds it is also wrong to say that it only applied to women because it does not say so in the Act.

The lawyer for the Supervisor of Elections, Nilesh Prasad says the Parliament has done what the court is being asked.

He says the matter has now become academic in nature and is hypothetical and they do not venture court make declaration that waste time.

Lal adds the documents and Parliament Hansard speak for itself.

The 7 women supported by the Fiji Women’s Rights Movement and the Fiji Women’s Crisis Centre had filed the constitutional challenge on the grounds of sex, gender and marital status discrimination and also on the basis that it violates the privacy and social and cultural identity of 100,000 Fijian women.

The 7 women are Lavinia Rose Bernadette Rounds Ganilau, Shiromani Priscilla Singh, Adi Davila Toganivalu, Elizabeth Reade Fong, Leba Seni Nabou, Yasmin Nisha Khan and Salote Raikolo Qalo.

FEATURE NEWS
Some of my Year 12 - 13 students are categorised as failures because they did not pass English - Natabua Principal
The Principal of Natabua High School Virendra Sharma is recommending that English should not be used to determine that a student passes his or her Yea...
15 hours ago
LATEST NEWS
Pope Leo XIV vows to work for unity in the church at inaugural mass
Pope Leo XIV has vowed to work for unity and condemned the exploitation of the poor. The ABC News reports that he was installed in a formal ...
26 minutes ago

Early years of a child’s life are foundational - Kiran
The early years of a child's life are crucial, shaping their health, education, and future potential, and the government is committed to Early ...
29 minutes ago

19 people injured after Mexican Navy training ship struck underside of Brooklyn Bridge in New York
A Mexican Navy training ship carrying 277 people struck the underside of the Brooklyn Bridge in New York, causing injuries to 19 people, including ...
15 hours ago

New HIV reports have risen fivefold in Fiji since 2019 - FNU
The new HIV infections report has risen fivefold in Fiji since 2019, with the highest number of cases reported in the Central Division. This has ...
15 hours ago

Fiji's Ministry of Trade strategically ahead in the queue for tariff talks with the US
As the clock ticks down on the US tariffs, the stakes rise and nobody wants to be out in the cold on July 8th but since mid-April, the Trump ...
15 hours ago



fijivillage Straight Talk with Vijay Narayan
Latest Videos

Stay tuned for the latest news on our radio stations

CFL radio frequencies
IN DEPTH

Tragedy at PRB Flats: Couple found dead in suspected murder-suicide in April
A couple were found dead at the new Lagilagi Public Rental Board Flats today and it is alleged at this stage that it was a murder suicide case on ...
14 days ago

Tevita Ikanivere on fijivillage Straight Talk With Vijay Narayan
The show focuses on Ikanivere’s journey, his family, career and how far the Drua has ...
27 days ago

TOP