Court of Appeal to deliver judgement on notice in the appeal case of Education Ministry against Vatuvonu SDA College

Court of Appeal to deliver judgement on notice in the appeal case of Education Ministry against Vatuvonu SDA College

By Naveel Krishant
Friday 14/02/2020
Vatuvonu SDA College [image: facebook]

The Fiji Court of Appeal will deliver its judgement on notice in the appeal of the Attorney General for and on behalf of the Ministry of Education against Vatuvonu SDA College and five trustees.

While making his submission on behalf of the Ministry of Education, Solicitor General Sharvada Sharma says the appointment of teachers is a constitutional right.

Sharma says any employee appointed by the Permanent Secretary of   Education is a public officer.

Sharma says Section 4 sub-section 3 of the Fijian constitution states that the state and religion are separate.

He says that the state and all persons in public office must respect all religions and they must not dictate any religious belief and must not prefer or advance, by any means, any particular religion, religious denomination, religious belief, or religious practice over another, or over any non-religious belief.

Sharma adds that any religious organization can appoint their own heads of schools provided they pay for their salaries.

The lawyer for the SDA Church, David Bennett says they have a constitutional right to not accept the ministry’s appointment of a Principal to it’s schools.

He says the constitution confers on the church the right to establish, maintain and manage schools and the exercise of that right means the church does not have to accept a Principal the Ministry of Education wishes to appoint to it’s schools.

Bennett says there is no law that obliges the church to accept such an appointment of a principal.

He adds if the Ministry of Education chooses to provide financial assistance to a school, it cannot make it a condition of such assistance that the school must accept any appointment made by the government because that is provided in Section 22 sub-section 4 and it would also have the effect of undermining the separation of religion and state as enshrined in section 4 of the Constitution.

This is in relation to the ruling by the High Court whereby it had ruled that the government is required to appoint a civil servant as Principal of Vatuvonu SDA College in terms of the Open Merit Recruitment Selection and in a manner consistent with the constitutional right in section 22(4) which means that the proposed appointment must be acceptable to the Church.

The section states that every religious community or denomination, and every cultural or social community, has the right to establish, maintain and manage places of education whether or not it receives financial assistance from the State, provided that the educational institution maintains any standard prescribed by law.

The High Court had also declined the application by the Attorney General's Office that sought an order that the five trustees of the Seventh Day Adventist Church in Fiji do not interfere with the Ministry of Education's right to appoint any suitable Head of the School and any Acting positions.

Stay tuned for the latest news on our radio stations

CFL radio frequencies
SODELPA spectacle
With SODELPA going through changes and opposition within the party, we give you all the stories that covered these ...
12 hours ago

USP Saga
All the build-up and stories as the USP Saga ...
17 hours ago

Fiji's approach to deal with effects of the COVID-19 Pandemic
As Fiji battles against the spread of the COVID-19 pandemic, many individuals and organisations have come forward to lend a helping ...
65 days ago
USP Council resolves to release BDO Report to Council members only
The USP Council has resolved that the BDO Report be released to Council members only. The Council is now in recess and will reconvene on Wednesday,...
9 hours ago
International USP student fined $100 for breach of curfew
A 20-year-old USP student has been fined $100 for breaching curfew. First-year Electrical Engineering student from Kiribati, Kata Kua, appeared ...
10 hours ago

880 drivers booked for improper loading and 861 drivers for overloading vehicles from January till May this year
880 drivers have been booked for improper loading and another 861 drivers for overloading vehicles from January till May this year with an extra 201 ...
11 hours ago

Report on Nestle UK and Fairtrade inaccurate – FSC CEO
The Fiji Sugar Corporation has today confirmed that it does not trade directly with Nestle UK and FSC does not expect any drop in their projected ...
12 hours ago

13-ton shipment of human hair seized in the US
A 13-ton shipment of beauty products such as weaves suspected to have been made out of human hair has been seized by US Customs and Border Protection ...
12 hours ago

Bail ruling for alleged Colo-I-Suva murderer later this month
The bail ruling for Sailosi Naivalurua who is accused of killing a man in Colo-i-Suva in April this year will be delivered by High Court Judge ...
12 hours ago