Chief Justice to deliver his ruling on notice in the matter where FTA has filed for a constitutional redress against 'no jab, no job' policy

Chief Justice to deliver his ruling on notice in the matter where FTA has filed for a constitutional redress against 'no jab, no job' policy

By Rashika Kumar
Thursday 10/03/2022
FTA General Secretary Paula Manumanunitoga with lawyer Simione Valenitabua and Devanesh Sharma with associate, Gul Fatima.

Chief Justice Kamal Kumar will deliver his ruling on notice in the matter where the Fijian Teachers Association has applied for a constitutional redress after more than 200 teachers lost their jobs for not getting the COVID-19 vaccine last year.

FTA is seeking a ruling that the 'no jab, no job' policy was unconstitutional as it breaches a person’s right against getting a scientific or medical treatment or procedures without an order of the court or without his or her informed consent, or if he or she is incapable of giving informed consent, without the informed consent of a lawful guardian.

They say it also breaches an individual’s right against direct or indirect discrimination on the grounds of their actual or supposed personal characteristics or circumstances, including race, culture, ethnic or social origin, colour, place of origin, sex, gender, sexual orientation, gender identity and expression, birth, primary language, economic or social or health status, disability, age, religion, conscience, marital status or pregnancy.

The FTA is represented by Simione Valenitabua while Devanesh Sharma and his associate, Gul Fatima are representing the Attorney General's Chambers, the Ministry of Employment and the State.

Valenitabua says if the Minister for Employment wanted to infringe on the right of a person against a medical procedure then they must have applied to the court and stated why the Vaccine Regulation is important, and then the court would have made a decision.

The lawyer also says for any public health issue, the Health Minister should be making the relevant laws however, the Employment Minister has usurped the Health Minister’s power by making provisions and applying it across the board when he has no power to do so constitutionally or through the Parliament.

He adds the Regulation is unlawful and unconstitutional as the Employment Minister has not informed the court that he is in compliance of the Constitution.

While responding to Valenitabua’s submissions, Sharma says the vaccination is not mandatory and no one is being forced to get vaccinated as they gave their consent.

Sharma says the rights of a person under the Regulation is diminished as the Health and Safety at Work Act is about protecting the health of employers, the staff and anyone who enters the work place.

He says it is a person’s choice but it comes with consequences and this is where the Regulation comes in to protect the workers so the requirement that a court order to limit the right does not hold because vaccination is not mandatory.

Devanesh Sharma says the Regulation does not take any right away from the Health Minister as the Health and Safety at Work Act covers everyone and not just the staff of the Health Ministry.

He says people must come to court with clean hands and FTA General Secretary Paula Manumanunitoga provides no evidence how they are protecting their workers and asks if they are adamant that vaccination is discriminatory then what independent research has been provided by FTA that the vaccination does not protect people.

Sharma adds the Regulation stated the Acts under which the power is given to the Permanent Secretary to enact the Regulation.

In his response to Sharma’s submission, Valenitabua says the FTA has not been closed down so they are in compliance with all relevant regulations.

Chief Justice Kumar asked if this means the staff are vaccinated to which Valenitabua responded that they are but they have been forced.

Valenitabua says the vaccination consent goes out the window because the Regulation forces them to get vaccinated or else they would lose their job.

FEATURE NEWS
Naduvalo double helps Fiji win Singapore 7s
The Fiji Airways Men’s National 7s side has won the HSBC Singapore 7s after beating Kenya 21-12 in the final thanks to a double by speedster Vuiviaw...
2 hours ago
LATEST NEWS
Embrace the teachings of the Ramayan - Prem Adarsh Ramayan Mandali
We should embrace the teachings of Lord Ram and the Ramayan that will benefit our lives. Preacher of Laqere Prem Adarsh Ramayan Mandali, Ishwar ...
8 hours ago

Quick action by NFA saves lives as fire breaks out in Nabua restaurant
A fire broke out at the Aosen Restaurant in Nabua this afternoon, however, quick action by the National Fire Authority saved lives. The owner of ...
10 hours ago

Argentina crowned World SVNS Series league winners after qualifying for semi finals in Singapore
Argentina have made history yet again after being crowned the 2024/2025 HSBC World SVNS Series league champions following their HSBC Singapore 7s ...
13 hours ago

PC Laliqavoka earns promotion to Corporal in recognition of dedication to duty
Police Constable Kaminieli Laliqavoka has been proudly promoted to the rank of Corporal by Police Commissioner Rusiate Tudravu, in recognition of his ...
13 hours ago

Kadavu Students Association at FNU and USP leads educational tour to empower island youth
The Kadavu Students Association, comprising students from both the University of the South Pacific and Fiji National University, has undertaken ...
13 hours ago



fijivillage Straight Talk with Vijay Narayan
Latest Videos

Stay tuned for the latest news on our radio stations

CFL radio frequencies
IN DEPTH
Swire Shipping Fijian Drua Coach, Glen Jackson appear on fijivillage Straight Talk With Vijay Narayan
Swire Shipping Fijian Drua Coach, Glen Jackson appeared on fijivillage Straight Talk With Vijay Narayan from the Drua base in Nadi. Coming off ...
4 days ago

Reverend Tugi on fijivillage Straight Talk With Vijay Narayan
Watch the General Secretary of Fiji Evangelical Fellowship, Reverend Simione Tugi on fijivillage Straight Talk With Vijay ...
39 days ago

fijivillage Straight Talk with Vijay Narayan and William Parkinson
Chairman of Communications Fiji Limited, parent company of FM96, LegendFM, VitiFM, Navtarang, Radio Sargam, fijivillage and PNGFM, William Parkinson ...
39 days ago

TOP