Justice Rajasinghe to sum up the Fiji Times sedition case on Friday

Justice Rajasinghe to sum up the Fiji Times sedition case on Friday

By Semi Turaga
16/05/2018
Hank Arts, Fred Wesley, Anare Ravula and Josaia Waqabaca

High Court Judge Justice Thushara Rajasinghe will sum up the Fiji Times sedition case on Friday before the three assessors retire behind closed doors to deliberate on their opinion.

While delivering the closing submission for the prosecution, Assistant DPP Lee Burney told the assessors that we have to take action now before the mosques and churches are burnt down.

We have to take action now before the mosques and churches are burnt down - Assistant DPP Lee Burney

He said it is not the Fiji Times that was courageous, it is the Permanent Secretary for Itaukei Affairs for condemning the article which was against Muslims.

He said what happens in this case is important for our country because it will determine what you can say in a national newspaper. Burney also said that ethno religious nationalism is a toxic influence.

He said the Fiji Times provided a platform for Josaia Waqabaca because without the Nai Lalakai, Waqabaca is just an old man sitting at home typing poisonous articles.

Burney said in this case, it is the Muslims that have been singled out and who is going to stand up when the next article comes up or when the next religion is singled out.

He also said it is no use saying after one week that it is old news because you have already planted the seed.

Josaia Waqabaca’s lawyer, Aman Ravindra Singh says the Attorney General has not been called to give evidence and it is safe to conclude that the original recipient had no issues.

Waqabaca was using his right of freedom of expression - Aman Ravindra Singh

He says Waqabaca simply wrote a letter expressing his concerns, adding that not a single complaint was lodged by a religious group while Muslims were mentioned.

Singh says two months later, the Permanent Secretary for iTaukei Affairs woke up, obviously directed by someone and filed a complaint.

Waqabaca’s lawyer says that Waqabaca was using his right of freedom of expression.

He questioned where is the evidence regarding seditious intention.

Singh also questioned on whether people were attacking people of the Muslim faith.

He concluded by saying that there was also not a single evidence by someone who said that my faith was attacked and there was no evidence from a village or rural area where the complaints were made.

Nai Lalakai’s editor, Anare Ravula’s lawyer, Devanesh Sharma in his closing submission says the letter is not seditious and the  letter is capable of having several meanings. He says that the letter contains issues of national interest.

The letter is not seditious and the letter is capable of having several meanings - Devanesh Sharma

Sharma says it does not tell you that Muslims of Fiji are capable of what Muslims in Bangladesh allegedly did.

Sharma also said that no one complained to the Media Industry Development Authority and neither did MIDA take any issue.

Hank Arts and Fred Wesley’s lawyer, Marc Corlett says all of the evidence shows that neither Arts nor Wesley knew about the letter. He says that the simple thing to do is to look at the letter as a whole and ask if the letter is seditious.

Corlett says the letter was persuading people to change things lawfully.

Wylie Clarke who is the lawyer for Fiji Times Limited says the prosecution is only focusing on the part about Muslims.

Wylie Clarke, Marc Corlett and Nicholas Barnes

Clarke says this is dangerous because the case is about a man who is troubled about what the government is doing.

He says you cannot ignore or suppress opinion just because you don't like it.

Clarke says the letter does not give an ultimatum and there was no such threat to the Attorney General. He says Fiji Times did everything it possibly could to ensure great care was taken to avoid this sort of situation.

FEATURE NEWS
Prof. Shameem calls on employers to pay workers what they are worth and there won't be a skill or labour crisis in Fiji
A stern message has been sent out to the employers in the country and that is for the private sector to face up to the reality that the labour crisis ...
2 hours ago
LATEST NEWS
Govt restores autonomy to schools, encourages greater involvement of parents
Restoring partnerships between school management, communities, religious organizations and parents is crucial to rebuilding and strengthening an ...
45 minutes ago

At least 21 children among dozens killed in Texas floods, as 11 girls from camp still missing
At least 69 people have been killed after flash floods swept through parts of central Texas. Kerrville County Sheriff Larry Leitha confirms 59 ...
1 hour ago

Akuila Qalo to lead traditional installation of Tui Nayau tomorrow
63-year-old Akuila Qalo, from the Matanivanua clan of Vuinayau will be traditionally installing the Tui Nayau, Ratu Tevita Uluilakeba Mara ...
1 hour ago

TLTB reduces national rental arrears to $22 million
The iTaukei Land Trust Board has successfully reduced its national rental arrears from $31.6 million as of 1st January, 2025 to $22 million by 30th ...
15 hours ago

Two man arrested over alleged yaqona thefts in Taveuni
A 35-year-old man and a 36-year-old man remain in police custody for their alleged involvement in a series of yaqona thefts in Taveuni. Acting ...
17 hours ago



fijivillage Straight Talk with Vijay Narayan
Latest Videos

Stay tuned for the latest news on our radio stations

CFL radio frequencies
IN DEPTH
CFL 40th Birthday
CFL’s 40th Anniversary celebrations to culminate with free concert at Albert Park on ...
3 days ago

Pacific Mini Games in Palau, 2025
Full coverage of Team Fiji's journey through the 2025 Palau Games.
4 days ago

Kamikamica, Biukoto and Shandil on fijivillage Straight Talk With Vijay Narayan
Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Communications Manoa Kamikamica, Vodafone Fiji's CEO Elenoa Biukoto and Consumer Council of Fiji CEO ...
4 days ago

TOP