High Court strikes out ATS Employees Trust’s application

High Court strikes out ATS Employees Trust’s application

By Vijay Narayan
13/02/2018
Jai D Singh and Viliame Finau

The High Court of Fiji in Lautoka has struck out and dismissed the application by the trustees of ATS Employees Trust, including Viliame Finau and Jai D Singh, against the Civil Aviation Authority of Fiji, the Attorney General on behalf of the Permanent Secretary for Economy, ATS Limited and the ATS company secretary.

ATS Employees Trust had alleged in it’s application that the re‑assignment of 51 percent of the shares of ATS from CAAF to the Government of Fiji in 2009 was in breach of the articles of association of ATS, the articles of association of ATS which expressly permitted the removal of directors of ATS was oppressive and prejudicial to ATS Employees Trust and that the removal of Jai D Singh, Manasa Ratuvili and Kevueli Tunidau from the board of directors of ATS was illegal, oppressive, null and void.

In its ruling, the Lautoka High Court Judge held that ATS Employees Trust’s application was a case which was both “bad in law” and “weak on evidence”, and struck out and wholly dismissed the application by ATS Employees Trust.

With respect to the claim against the re‑assignment of 51 percent of ATS shares from CAAF to the Government, the High Court noted that ATS Employees Trust was aware as early as October 2009 of the re‑assignment, and that the Employees Trust did not raise any objection to the re‑assignment since October 2009.

The High Court also noted from the evidence that ATS Employees Trust had accepted and acquiesced to the re‑assignment.

The High Court further held the re‑assignment of shares from CAAF to Government did not change the shareholding of ATS as it was only an internal arrangement between two government entities which was legal and approved by Cabinet. The High Court affirmed that Government is still the majority shareholder and that the majority shares are now held by the Ministry of Economy on behalf of Government instead of CAAF.

In response to ATS Employees Trust’s claim against the removal of Jai D Singh, Manasa Ratuvili, and Kevueli Tunidau from the ATS Board of Directors, the High Court held that the removal of directors was done in accordance with the Articles of Association of ATS, which was formulated when ATS was formed in 1980.

In striking out and dismissing the Employees Trust’s application in its entirety, the High Court ordered the Trust to pay costs to CAAF, the Attorney General, ATS, and the ATS company secretary in the sum of $4,000.

FEATURE NEWS
A quarter pound of Rewa Butter to cost $4 from tomorrow
Get ready to dig deeper into your pockets as Rewa Butter prices will increase from tomorrow. A quarter pound of butter which used to cost $3.51 wil...
4 hours ago
LATEST NEWS
Radrodro says Dr Hasmukh Lal leaves behind a legacy of innovation and inclusivity in education
The Minister for Education, Aseri Radrodro says the work of the CEO of Tertiary Scholarships and Loans Service, Hasmukh Lal has helped students from ...
6 minutes ago

Trump says EU and Mexico face 30% tariff from August
President Donald Trump has announced that the European Union and Mexico will face a 30 percent tariff on imports to the US from 1st August. He ...
2 hours ago

Vishva Hindu Parishad condemns calls for stronger protection of places of worship
The Vishva Hindu Parishad Fiji has strongly denounced the heinous desecration of sacred idols at the Sanatan Shiv Mandir in Samabula on Friday and is ...
3 hours ago

Ro Filipe raises concern over 7% unutilised Ministry budget
Minister for Public Works Ro Filipe Tuisawau says his Ministry’s unutilised budget of 7 percent is a concern and he is urging all Heads of ...
3 hours ago

Chaudhry says temple desecration incident may have been caused by a person believed to be mentally impaired
Fiji Labour Party Leader Mahendra Chaudhry has expressed concern at the desecration of Hindu idols at the Samabula Shiv Mandir but has cautioned ...
6 hours ago



fijivillage Straight Talk with Vijay Narayan
Latest Videos

Stay tuned for the latest news on our radio stations

CFL radio frequencies
IN DEPTH
Professor Prasad on fijivillage Straight Talk With Vijay Narayan
The show will focus on the 2025/2026 National Budget.
4 days ago

Tui Nayau and Tui Lau Installation
The ceremony for the installation of the Tui Nayau Sau ni Vanua o Lau will be held tomorrow, while the installation ceremony of the Tui Lau will be held in Tubou on Thursday.
6 days ago

CFL 40th Birthday
CFL’s 40th Anniversary celebrations to culminate with free concert at Albert Park on ...
9 days ago

TOP